Boise Water Heater Repair
The gas control valve and supply line on a gas water heater (illustrative photo)

Gas vs. Electric Water Heaters and Sizing in Boise

Not sure whether to stay with gas or go electric in Boise? Find your fuel, compare the two and size the tank, then call or text for a quote.

Updated Prices checked

  • Find your fuel in a minute
  • Sizing by household, explained
  • Price quoted before work begins

Water heater trouble?

Water heater trouble? Tell me what's going on, and I'll get right back to you.

* required

!Please enter your name.
!Please enter a 10-digit phone number.

Answered 24/7. Rather talk? Call or text (208) 248-9840.

Most homeowners don't choose between gas and electric from scratch. The pipe or cable already coming into the house chooses for them, and switching costs money. This guide helps you confirm what you have, compare the two honestly and pick a size.

What does my water heater run on?

Look at the tank. A flue pipe on top and a gas line with a control dial mean gas. A thick cable into the side and a pair of square panels mean electric.

  • Gas: a window near the base shows the flame, and the label names natural gas or propane.
  • Electric: a breaker labeled for the water heater, and heating elements under the side panels.
  • Heat pump: an electric tank with a fan unit on top and, often, an ENERGY STAR label.
  • Tankless: a wall box; its label states the fuel.

Who supplies gas and electricity in Boise?

Intermountain Gas Company supplies natural gas, and its list of communities includes Boise and Garden City. Idaho Power, headquartered in Boise, is the electric company for much of the area. Neither list proves service at a specific address, so check your bill or the utility's own tools.

Hidden Springs is not on Intermountain Gas's list, which is a good reminder that gas availability varies by community and sometimes by street. If you are unsure, call the utility before planning a gas heater.

How do gas and electric tanks compare?

Both heat water reliably, and the differences are in the install and the running cost.

Gas tankElectric tank
Install needsgas line, flue, shutoff, connectorcircuit and a disconnect in sight
Heats back upfastslower
Typical installed rangeabout $1,000–$3,400 (tank, either fuel)about $1,000–$3,400 (tank, either fuel)
Rules in the City's guidemetal or listed drain pan; gas flex under 24 inches; CO alarmwiring in conduit; elements 18 inches up in a garage
Rebate herenone listed for tanks$300 for a heat-pump model

Utility rates change, so compare the current Intermountain Gas and Idaho Power prices for your own bill instead of trusting a number in print. The tank's price is similar either way; the difference is usually in what the house needs around it.

What does the City of Boise require for each?

The City's June 2025 Water Heater Installation Guide sets the checklist. Some items depend on fuel.

  • Gas: a gas shutoff within 6 feet, a new flex connector no longer than 24 inches, a dip leg ahead of the valve and burner and ignitor at least 18 inches above a garage floor.
  • Electric in a garage: the lowest element at least 18 inches up, with wiring in conduit.
  • Both: a relief valve with a full-size discharge line, a drain pan on any floor other than concrete, and an expansion tank when the plumbing is a closed system.
  • Carbon monoxide: an alarm outside sleeping areas wherever a fuel-fired appliance or an attached garage exists.

Under Idaho law, the gas connection is done by a licensed plumber or an HVAC-licensed contractor, while an HVAC or electrical license also covers the power connection when the circuit is 50 feet or less with the disconnect in sight.

Choosing between gas and electric? Call or text and get both options priced.

(208) 248-9840Talk to a plumber 24/7Text Us

Does Boise's altitude matter for a gas heater?

Yes, enough to check. NWS puts Boise's airport at 2,871 feet, and the city varies between 2,500 and 2,850 feet. Gas heaters are built for sea level to 2,000 feet unless the label says otherwise, and above that you should contact the dealer or maker about modification.

The gas control valve and supply line on a gas water heater
A gas tank's flue and gas line are where altitude and code both come into play.

The adjustment, if any, depends on the model, so the maker is the one to answer it. The point is simple: ask whether the exact unit you are quoted suits Boise's elevation. Electric heaters have no burner to worry about.

What size water heater do I need?

Start with the household, then think about peak use. Rheem's guidance is a good baseline.

People in the houseTank size
1–230–40 gallons
2–440–50 gallons
4–550–55 gallons
5 or more75 gallons, or tankless

Peak use is what trips households up. Two showers, a dishwasher and a washer in one morning can drain a tank sized for the average day. If that is your routine, go up a size or look at the tankless option.

Should I think about a heat pump?

If you have an electric tank now, a heat-pump water heater is worth a look. ENERGY STAR heat-pump models show a Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) of 3.3 to 4.1, far above a plain resistance tank, which means less power for the same hot water.

Idaho Power's $300 incentive applies to an Idaho Power customer who owns the home, with a unit on its Products List at Tier 2 or above, 55 gallons or less, replacing an electric-resistance storage heater. It is one per home. Check the current amount first, since no end date is posted.

What is the safe thermostat setting?

The Consumer Product Safety Commission urges 120 degrees. At 140 degrees a scald happens in about 5 seconds, and at 130 in about 30. Idaho deletes the model code's scald-valve provision, so there is no state rule requiring one; the thermostat setting is your protection.

For the install steps, permit and total cost, read the installation service page, then get your quote.

Ready to size and price your next heater? Call or text any hour.

(208) 248-9840Talk to a plumber 24/7Text Us

Questions homeowners ask

Is gas or electric better for a water heater in Boise?

Gas often heats faster and keeps working in a power cut if the model has a standing pilot, while electric needs no flue and is simpler to install. The better choice usually follows the fuel already in the house.

Who supplies natural gas in Boise?

Intermountain Gas Company lists Boise and Garden City among its communities. Whether gas reaches a particular street is something to confirm with the utility, not assume.

What size water heater do I need?

Rheem's guidance is 30 to 40 gallons for 1 to 2 people, 40 to 50 for 2 to 4, 50 to 55 for 4 to 5, and 75 gallons or tankless for 5 or more. Peak use, such as two showers and a dishwasher together, can push you up a size.

Is there a rebate for an electric water heater from Idaho Power?

Idaho Power offers $300 toward a heat-pump water heater of 55 gallons or less that replaces an electric-resistance tank, for a customer who owns the home. No end date is posted, so check the current amount.

Can I switch from electric to gas?

Only if gas piping can reach the heater, and then the gas line, venting and permits become part of the job. It is rarely the cheapest route unless the gas line is already close.

Last updated:

Text Boise Water Heater Repair

Tell me what's going on with your water heater, and I'll get right back to you.

* required

!Please enter your name.
!Please enter a 10-digit phone number.

Rather talk? Call or text (208) 248-9840.